Cockpit으로AI Coding Tools 허브로

공개 문서

Phase Index (LAB)

아래는 learn/lab/phase-index.md 와 동일한 원문입니다. Markdown과 HTML 변환 결과를 각각 복사할 수 있습니다.

공개 문서 원문 (Markdown)

# Phase Index — Cursor Harness LAB (Phase 10–26)

> 작업 경로 (2020): `<local-path>/server/Desktop/MultiAgentSystem`  
> 원본: `multi-agent-system/runs/run-00N-*/`

---

## Phase 10 — Run 001: Production-like (LAB)

- **경로:** `multi-agent-system/runs/run-001-production-like/`
- **목적:** Slack → Hermes/OpenClaw → Cursor → 결과보고 → AI AX Learning Hub 흐름에 맞는 production-like run 템플릿을 LAB 내부에서 검증한다.
- **결과:**
  - run.md, approval.md, context.md, worker brief/output 3종, envelope(json+md), final-report 완료
  - codex / claude / gemini worker 3/3 SUCCESS
  - `safe_to_apply: false`, `approval_required: true`
- **상태:** PASS
- **Learning Hub 반영 포인트:** file-as-memory run 구조, envelope 패턴, worker smoke baseline, Hub handoff 후보 식별

---

## Phase 11 — Run 002: MCP Primary + Slack Stub

- **경로:** `multi-agent-system/runs/run-002-mcp-slack-stub/`
- **목적:** Slack 요청/승인/알림을 API 없이 stub 문서로 검증하고 codex MCP primary 경로를 재확인한다.
- **결과:**
  - slack-stub 문서 세트, MCP primary SUCCESS
  - worker 3종 SUCCESS, `slack_api_called: false`
- **상태:** PASS
- **Learning Hub 반영 포인트:** Slack stub 패턴, MCP primary vs CLI fallback, 승인 흐름 문서화

---

## Phase 12 — Run 003: Hermes Stub + Cursor Harness

- **경로:** `multi-agent-system/runs/run-003-hermes-stub/`
- **목적:** Hermes/OpenClaw 실행 단계를 컨테이너 호출 없이 stub으로 검증하고 Cursor Harness run에 연결한다.
- **결과:**
  - hermes-stub handoff/execution/result-report 문서
  - worker 3종 SUCCESS; claude NO-GO 2항 보완 권고
- **상태:** PASS
- **Learning Hub 반영 포인트:** Hermes handoff/execution stub, 수동알림(OAuth/SSH) 분기, read-only 연동 설계 기초

---

## Phase 13 — Run 004: E2E Stub Chain

- **경로:** `multi-agent-system/runs/run-004-e2e-stub-chain/`
- **목적:** Slack → Hermes → Cursor → 결과보고 → Hub 전 구간을 `chain/01~08` stub chain으로 E2E 검증한다.
- **결과:**
  - chain 8단계 OK; `07-learning-hub-source.md` Hub 저장 구조 정의
  - MCP primary SUCCESS; gemini 수동알림 즉시성 FAIL → 보완 권고
- **상태:** PASS
- **Learning Hub 반영 포인트:** E2E artifact 목록, Hub source YAML 스키마, MD/HTML/PPT 재사용 형식

---

## Phase 14 — Run 005: Gateway Contract Stub-First

- **경로:** `multi-agent-system/runs/run-005-gateway-contract-stub/`
- **목적:** 업무자동화 흐름을 gateway contract 후보 7종으로 정리한다 (stub-first, API 미호출).
- **결과:**
  - contracts 01–07 (06 Learning Hub Source contract 포함)
  - gateway-envelope schema, worker 3종 SUCCESS
- **상태:** PASS
- **Learning Hub 반영 포인트:** Contract 06 필드(`source_type`, `markdown_path`, `reusable_tags`), gateway envelope 패턴

---

## Phase 15 — Run 006: Dry-run Gateway

- **경로:** `multi-agent-system/runs/run-006-dry-run-gateway/`
- **목적:** Gateway contract를 local dry-run adapter 입출력으로 검증한다 (API 미호출).
- **결과:**
  - adapter dry-run 입출력 검증, schema OK
  - MCP primary SUCCESS, worker 3종 SUCCESS
- **상태:** PASS
- **Learning Hub 반영 포인트:** stub→adapter 전환, dry_run gateway_mode, live 전환 전 검증 단계

---

## Phase 16 — Run 007: Limited Live Pilot Design

- **경로:** `multi-agent-system/runs/run-007-limited-live-pilot-design/`
- **목적:** Limited Live Pilot을 실제 실행하지 않고 설계한다.
- **결과:**
  - pilot 설계 문서, limited-live schema
  - MCP primary SUCCESS; `approved_for_live_execution: false`
- **상태:** PASS (설계 100%)
- **Learning Hub 반영 포인트:** limited live 범위·제한·승인 게이트 설계, Hermes read-only / Hub sandbox only 원칙

---

## Phase 17 — Run 008: Live Pilot Approval Package

- **경로:** `multi-agent-system/runs/run-008-live-pilot-approval-package/`
- **목적:** Limited Live Pilot 1건 실행 전 사용자 승인 패키지를 작성한다 (live 실행 아님).
- **결과:**
  - approval-package 문서, Go/No-Go checklist (NO-GO)
  - worker 3종 SUCCESS
- **상태:** PASS
- **Learning Hub 반영 포인트:** 승인 패키지 템플릿, explicit approval 요구사항

---

## Phase 18 — Run 009: Limited Live Pilot Preflight

- **경로:** `multi-agent-system/runs/run-009-limited-live-pilot-preflight/`
- **목적:** Limited Live Pilot 1건 실행 직전 preflight run을 생성한다.
- **결과:**
  - preflight 체크리스트, envelope preflight mode
  - MCP + worker SUCCESS; live 미실행
- **상태:** PASS
- **Learning Hub 반영 포인트:** preflight 게이트, 실행 직전 확인 항목

---

## Phase 19 — Run 010: Limited Live Pilot 001

- **경로:** `multi-agent-system/runs/run-010-limited-live-pilot-001/`
- **목적:** Limited Live Pilot 1건을 제한된 범위에서 실행하고 결과를 보고한다.
- **결과:**
  - LAB harness 100%; Slack/Hermes/Hub external **BLOCKED** (channel/endpoint unclear)
  - `slack_api_called: false`, `hub_api_called: false`
  - worker 4종 SUCCESS (MCP 포함)
- **상태:** PASS (조건부 — LAB complete, API BLOCKED)
- **Learning Hub 반영 포인트:** BLOCKED 사유 문서화, live vs LAB 성공 기준 분리

---

## Phase 20 — Run 011: Live Blocker Readiness Check

- **경로:** `multi-agent-system/runs/run-011-live-blocker-readiness-check/`
- **목적:** Phase 19 BLOCKED 원인을 live 실행 없이 해소 가능한지 확인한다.
- **결과:**
  - readiness 5종 문서; Slack/Hermes/Hub endpoint **not_confirmed / not_configured**
  - `phase21_readiness: NO-GO`; Mac Terminal 수동 확인 placeholder
- **상태:** PASS (패키지); Phase 21 live 재시도 **불가 (NO-GO)**
- **Learning Hub 반영 포인트:** readiness 체크리스트, terminal-checks 패턴, NO-GO 기록의 학습 가치

---

## Phase 21 — Run 012: Limited Live Pilot Retry 001

- **경로:** `multi-agent-system/runs/run-012-limited-live-pilot-retry-001/`
- **목적:** Phase 20 readiness confirmed 상태로 Limited Live Pilot 1건 재시도.
- **결과:**
  - readiness import GO; Slack/Hermes/Hub 시도 모두 **BLOCKED** (no executable client)
  - LAB harness 100%; external live API 0%
- **상태:** PASS (LAB + BLOCKED documented)
- **Learning Hub 반영 포인트:** runtime path 부재가 BLOCKED 원인임을 명시 → Phase 22 설계로 연결

---

## Phase 22 — Run 013: Runtime Path Design

- **경로:** `multi-agent-system/runs/run-013-runtime-path-design/`
- **목적:** Slack/Hermes/Hub runtime path 부재를 해소하기 위한 설계 문서와 wrapper design을 작성한다.
- **결과:**
  - runtime-path 3종 (Slack post MCP, Hermes RO, Hub sandbox)
  - wrapper design 3종; MCP SUCCESS; live **NO-GO**
- **상태:** PASS
- **Learning Hub 반영 포인트:** client path 설계, sandbox=true 강제, production 차단 원칙

---

## Phase 23 — Run 014: Wrapper Integration Dry-run

- **경로:** `multi-agent-system/runs/run-014-wrapper-integration-dry-run/`
- **목적:** wrapper 3종을 LAB에서 구현하고 integration dry-run으로 검증한다.
- **결과:**
  - slack/hermes/hub wrapper `dry_run_ready`; integration summary **pass**
  - outputs-2020-smoke 재검증; `hub_api_called: false`
- **상태:** PASS; live execution **NO-GO**
- **Learning Hub 반영 포인트:** wrapper 구현·fixture·redaction 패턴, 2020 smoke 출력 구조

---

## Phase 24 — Run 015: Live Retry 002 Approval & Env Readiness

- **경로:** `multi-agent-system/runs/run-015-live-retry-002-approval-env-readiness/`
- **목적:** Limited Live Retry 002 실행 전 env outside LAB 기준과 사용자 승인 패키지를 확정한다.
- **결과:**
  - env-readiness 7종, wrapper live switch check PASS (design)
  - Go/No-Go: **NO-GO live** / **GO Phase 25 preflight**
- **상태:** PASS
- **Learning Hub 반영 포인트:** env outside LAB 정책, redaction/log policy, 승인 메시지 템플릿

---

## Phase 25 — Run 016: Env False NO-GO Remediation

- **경로:** `multi-agent-system/runs/run-016-env-false-nogo-remediation/`
- **목적:** env readiness false 결과를 기록하고 보완 계획을 작성한다.
- **결과:**
  - SLACK/HERMES/HUB env **false** (3/3 unset)
  - env-status 보완 문서 5종; `phase26_readiness: no_go`
- **상태:** PASS (NO-GO 기록 + 보완 문서 완료)
- **Learning Hub 반영 포인트:** Mac Terminal setup guide, required env keys (이름만), false NO-GO remediation 흐름

---

## Phase 26 — Run 017: 2020 Readiness Confirmation

- **경로:** `multi-agent-system/runs/run-017-2020-readiness-confirmation/`
- **목적:** 2019 → 2020 이전 후 env readiness 및 wrapper dry-run 재확인.
- **결과:**
  - SLACK/HUB/HERMES readiness **true** (2020 Mac)
  - secret/env/token 파일 미복사; wrapper dry-run recheck pass
  - **NO LIVE EXECUTION YET**
- **상태:** README only (formal PHASE report 없음)
- **Learning Hub 반영 포인트:** 마이그레이션 완료 기록, 2020-safe wrapper path 선행 조건, live 실행 전 게이트

---

## Phase 순서 요약표

| Phase | Run | 제목 | 상태 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | 001 | Production-like (LAB) | PASS |
| 11 | 002 | MCP Primary + Slack Stub | PASS |
| 12 | 003 | Hermes Stub | PASS |
| 13 | 004 | E2E Stub Chain | PASS |
| 14 | 005 | Gateway Contract Stub | PASS |
| 15 | 006 | Dry-run Gateway | PASS |
| 16 | 007 | Limited Live Pilot Design | PASS |
| 17 | 008 | Live Pilot Approval Package | PASS |
| 18 | 009 | Limited Live Preflight | PASS |
| 19 | 010 | Limited Live Pilot 001 | PASS (조건부) |
| 20 | 011 | Live Blocker Readiness | PASS / NO-GO |
| 21 | 012 | Live Pilot Retry 001 | PASS (BLOCKED) |
| 22 | 013 | Runtime Path Design | PASS |
| 23 | 014 | Wrapper Integration Dry-run | PASS |
| 24 | 015 | Live Retry 002 Env Readiness | PASS |
| 25 | 016 | Env False NO-GO Remediation | PASS (NO-GO) |
| 26 | 017 | 2020 Readiness Confirmation | README only |

공개 문서 변환 코드 (HTML)

<h1>Phase Index — Cursor Harness LAB (Phase 10–26)</h1>
<blockquote>
<p>작업 경로 (2020): <code>&lt;local-path&gt;/server/Desktop/MultiAgentSystem</code><br>원본: <code>multi-agent-system/runs/run-00N-*/</code></p>
</blockquote>
<hr>
<h2>Phase 10 — Run 001: Production-like (LAB)</h2>
<ul>
<li><strong>경로:</strong> <code>multi-agent-system/runs/run-001-production-like/</code></li>
<li><strong>목적:</strong> Slack → Hermes/OpenClaw → Cursor → 결과보고 → AI AX Learning Hub 흐름에 맞는 production-like run 템플릿을 LAB 내부에서 검증한다.</li>
<li><strong>결과:</strong><ul>
<li>run.md, approval.md, context.md, worker brief/output 3종, envelope(json+md), final-report 완료</li>
<li>codex / claude / gemini worker 3/3 SUCCESS</li>
<li><code>safe_to_apply: false</code>, <code>approval_required: true</code></li>
</ul>
</li>
<li><strong>상태:</strong> PASS</li>
<li><strong>Learning Hub 반영 포인트:</strong> file-as-memory run 구조, envelope 패턴, worker smoke baseline, Hub handoff 후보 식별</li>
</ul>
<hr>
<h2>Phase 11 — Run 002: MCP Primary + Slack Stub</h2>
<ul>
<li><strong>경로:</strong> <code>multi-agent-system/runs/run-002-mcp-slack-stub/</code></li>
<li><strong>목적:</strong> Slack 요청/승인/알림을 API 없이 stub 문서로 검증하고 codex MCP primary 경로를 재확인한다.</li>
<li><strong>결과:</strong><ul>
<li>slack-stub 문서 세트, MCP primary SUCCESS</li>
<li>worker 3종 SUCCESS, <code>slack_api_called: false</code></li>
</ul>
</li>
<li><strong>상태:</strong> PASS</li>
<li><strong>Learning Hub 반영 포인트:</strong> Slack stub 패턴, MCP primary vs CLI fallback, 승인 흐름 문서화</li>
</ul>
<hr>
<h2>Phase 12 — Run 003: Hermes Stub + Cursor Harness</h2>
<ul>
<li><strong>경로:</strong> <code>multi-agent-system/runs/run-003-hermes-stub/</code></li>
<li><strong>목적:</strong> Hermes/OpenClaw 실행 단계를 컨테이너 호출 없이 stub으로 검증하고 Cursor Harness run에 연결한다.</li>
<li><strong>결과:</strong><ul>
<li>hermes-stub handoff/execution/result-report 문서</li>
<li>worker 3종 SUCCESS; claude NO-GO 2항 보완 권고</li>
</ul>
</li>
<li><strong>상태:</strong> PASS</li>
<li><strong>Learning Hub 반영 포인트:</strong> Hermes handoff/execution stub, 수동알림(OAuth/SSH) 분기, read-only 연동 설계 기초</li>
</ul>
<hr>
<h2>Phase 13 — Run 004: E2E Stub Chain</h2>
<ul>
<li><strong>경로:</strong> <code>multi-agent-system/runs/run-004-e2e-stub-chain/</code></li>
<li><strong>목적:</strong> Slack → Hermes → Cursor → 결과보고 → Hub 전 구간을 <code>chain/01~08</code> stub chain으로 E2E 검증한다.</li>
<li><strong>결과:</strong><ul>
<li>chain 8단계 OK; <code>07-learning-hub-source.md</code> Hub 저장 구조 정의</li>
<li>MCP primary SUCCESS; gemini 수동알림 즉시성 FAIL → 보완 권고</li>
</ul>
</li>
<li><strong>상태:</strong> PASS</li>
<li><strong>Learning Hub 반영 포인트:</strong> E2E artifact 목록, Hub source YAML 스키마, MD/HTML/PPT 재사용 형식</li>
</ul>
<hr>
<h2>Phase 14 — Run 005: Gateway Contract Stub-First</h2>
<ul>
<li><strong>경로:</strong> <code>multi-agent-system/runs/run-005-gateway-contract-stub/</code></li>
<li><strong>목적:</strong> 업무자동화 흐름을 gateway contract 후보 7종으로 정리한다 (stub-first, API 미호출).</li>
<li><strong>결과:</strong><ul>
<li>contracts 01–07 (06 Learning Hub Source contract 포함)</li>
<li>gateway-envelope schema, worker 3종 SUCCESS</li>
</ul>
</li>
<li><strong>상태:</strong> PASS</li>
<li><strong>Learning Hub 반영 포인트:</strong> Contract 06 필드(<code>source_type</code>, <code>markdown_path</code>, <code>reusable_tags</code>), gateway envelope 패턴</li>
</ul>
<hr>
<h2>Phase 15 — Run 006: Dry-run Gateway</h2>
<ul>
<li><strong>경로:</strong> <code>multi-agent-system/runs/run-006-dry-run-gateway/</code></li>
<li><strong>목적:</strong> Gateway contract를 local dry-run adapter 입출력으로 검증한다 (API 미호출).</li>
<li><strong>결과:</strong><ul>
<li>adapter dry-run 입출력 검증, schema OK</li>
<li>MCP primary SUCCESS, worker 3종 SUCCESS</li>
</ul>
</li>
<li><strong>상태:</strong> PASS</li>
<li><strong>Learning Hub 반영 포인트:</strong> stub→adapter 전환, dry_run gateway_mode, live 전환 전 검증 단계</li>
</ul>
<hr>
<h2>Phase 16 — Run 007: Limited Live Pilot Design</h2>
<ul>
<li><strong>경로:</strong> <code>multi-agent-system/runs/run-007-limited-live-pilot-design/</code></li>
<li><strong>목적:</strong> Limited Live Pilot을 실제 실행하지 않고 설계한다.</li>
<li><strong>결과:</strong><ul>
<li>pilot 설계 문서, limited-live schema</li>
<li>MCP primary SUCCESS; <code>approved_for_live_execution: false</code></li>
</ul>
</li>
<li><strong>상태:</strong> PASS (설계 100%)</li>
<li><strong>Learning Hub 반영 포인트:</strong> limited live 범위·제한·승인 게이트 설계, Hermes read-only / Hub sandbox only 원칙</li>
</ul>
<hr>
<h2>Phase 17 — Run 008: Live Pilot Approval Package</h2>
<ul>
<li><strong>경로:</strong> <code>multi-agent-system/runs/run-008-live-pilot-approval-package/</code></li>
<li><strong>목적:</strong> Limited Live Pilot 1건 실행 전 사용자 승인 패키지를 작성한다 (live 실행 아님).</li>
<li><strong>결과:</strong><ul>
<li>approval-package 문서, Go/No-Go checklist (NO-GO)</li>
<li>worker 3종 SUCCESS</li>
</ul>
</li>
<li><strong>상태:</strong> PASS</li>
<li><strong>Learning Hub 반영 포인트:</strong> 승인 패키지 템플릿, explicit approval 요구사항</li>
</ul>
<hr>
<h2>Phase 18 — Run 009: Limited Live Pilot Preflight</h2>
<ul>
<li><strong>경로:</strong> <code>multi-agent-system/runs/run-009-limited-live-pilot-preflight/</code></li>
<li><strong>목적:</strong> Limited Live Pilot 1건 실행 직전 preflight run을 생성한다.</li>
<li><strong>결과:</strong><ul>
<li>preflight 체크리스트, envelope preflight mode</li>
<li>MCP + worker SUCCESS; live 미실행</li>
</ul>
</li>
<li><strong>상태:</strong> PASS</li>
<li><strong>Learning Hub 반영 포인트:</strong> preflight 게이트, 실행 직전 확인 항목</li>
</ul>
<hr>
<h2>Phase 19 — Run 010: Limited Live Pilot 001</h2>
<ul>
<li><strong>경로:</strong> <code>multi-agent-system/runs/run-010-limited-live-pilot-001/</code></li>
<li><strong>목적:</strong> Limited Live Pilot 1건을 제한된 범위에서 실행하고 결과를 보고한다.</li>
<li><strong>결과:</strong><ul>
<li>LAB harness 100%; Slack/Hermes/Hub external <strong>BLOCKED</strong> (channel/endpoint unclear)</li>
<li><code>slack_api_called: false</code>, <code>hub_api_called: false</code></li>
<li>worker 4종 SUCCESS (MCP 포함)</li>
</ul>
</li>
<li><strong>상태:</strong> PASS (조건부 — LAB complete, API BLOCKED)</li>
<li><strong>Learning Hub 반영 포인트:</strong> BLOCKED 사유 문서화, live vs LAB 성공 기준 분리</li>
</ul>
<hr>
<h2>Phase 20 — Run 011: Live Blocker Readiness Check</h2>
<ul>
<li><strong>경로:</strong> <code>multi-agent-system/runs/run-011-live-blocker-readiness-check/</code></li>
<li><strong>목적:</strong> Phase 19 BLOCKED 원인을 live 실행 없이 해소 가능한지 확인한다.</li>
<li><strong>결과:</strong><ul>
<li>readiness 5종 문서; Slack/Hermes/Hub endpoint <strong>not_confirmed / not_configured</strong></li>
<li><code>phase21_readiness: NO-GO</code>; Mac Terminal 수동 확인 placeholder</li>
</ul>
</li>
<li><strong>상태:</strong> PASS (패키지); Phase 21 live 재시도 <strong>불가 (NO-GO)</strong></li>
<li><strong>Learning Hub 반영 포인트:</strong> readiness 체크리스트, terminal-checks 패턴, NO-GO 기록의 학습 가치</li>
</ul>
<hr>
<h2>Phase 21 — Run 012: Limited Live Pilot Retry 001</h2>
<ul>
<li><strong>경로:</strong> <code>multi-agent-system/runs/run-012-limited-live-pilot-retry-001/</code></li>
<li><strong>목적:</strong> Phase 20 readiness confirmed 상태로 Limited Live Pilot 1건 재시도.</li>
<li><strong>결과:</strong><ul>
<li>readiness import GO; Slack/Hermes/Hub 시도 모두 <strong>BLOCKED</strong> (no executable client)</li>
<li>LAB harness 100%; external live API 0%</li>
</ul>
</li>
<li><strong>상태:</strong> PASS (LAB + BLOCKED documented)</li>
<li><strong>Learning Hub 반영 포인트:</strong> runtime path 부재가 BLOCKED 원인임을 명시 → Phase 22 설계로 연결</li>
</ul>
<hr>
<h2>Phase 22 — Run 013: Runtime Path Design</h2>
<ul>
<li><strong>경로:</strong> <code>multi-agent-system/runs/run-013-runtime-path-design/</code></li>
<li><strong>목적:</strong> Slack/Hermes/Hub runtime path 부재를 해소하기 위한 설계 문서와 wrapper design을 작성한다.</li>
<li><strong>결과:</strong><ul>
<li>runtime-path 3종 (Slack post MCP, Hermes RO, Hub sandbox)</li>
<li>wrapper design 3종; MCP SUCCESS; live <strong>NO-GO</strong></li>
</ul>
</li>
<li><strong>상태:</strong> PASS</li>
<li><strong>Learning Hub 반영 포인트:</strong> client path 설계, sandbox=true 강제, production 차단 원칙</li>
</ul>
<hr>
<h2>Phase 23 — Run 014: Wrapper Integration Dry-run</h2>
<ul>
<li><strong>경로:</strong> <code>multi-agent-system/runs/run-014-wrapper-integration-dry-run/</code></li>
<li><strong>목적:</strong> wrapper 3종을 LAB에서 구현하고 integration dry-run으로 검증한다.</li>
<li><strong>결과:</strong><ul>
<li>slack/hermes/hub wrapper <code>dry_run_ready</code>; integration summary <strong>pass</strong></li>
<li>outputs-2020-smoke 재검증; <code>hub_api_called: false</code></li>
</ul>
</li>
<li><strong>상태:</strong> PASS; live execution <strong>NO-GO</strong></li>
<li><strong>Learning Hub 반영 포인트:</strong> wrapper 구현·fixture·redaction 패턴, 2020 smoke 출력 구조</li>
</ul>
<hr>
<h2>Phase 24 — Run 015: Live Retry 002 Approval &amp; Env Readiness</h2>
<ul>
<li><strong>경로:</strong> <code>multi-agent-system/runs/run-015-live-retry-002-approval-env-readiness/</code></li>
<li><strong>목적:</strong> Limited Live Retry 002 실행 전 env outside LAB 기준과 사용자 승인 패키지를 확정한다.</li>
<li><strong>결과:</strong><ul>
<li>env-readiness 7종, wrapper live switch check PASS (design)</li>
<li>Go/No-Go: <strong>NO-GO live</strong> / <strong>GO Phase 25 preflight</strong></li>
</ul>
</li>
<li><strong>상태:</strong> PASS</li>
<li><strong>Learning Hub 반영 포인트:</strong> env outside LAB 정책, redaction/log policy, 승인 메시지 템플릿</li>
</ul>
<hr>
<h2>Phase 25 — Run 016: Env False NO-GO Remediation</h2>
<ul>
<li><strong>경로:</strong> <code>multi-agent-system/runs/run-016-env-false-nogo-remediation/</code></li>
<li><strong>목적:</strong> env readiness false 결과를 기록하고 보완 계획을 작성한다.</li>
<li><strong>결과:</strong><ul>
<li>SLACK/HERMES/HUB env <strong>false</strong> (3/3 unset)</li>
<li>env-status 보완 문서 5종; <code>phase26_readiness: no_go</code></li>
</ul>
</li>
<li><strong>상태:</strong> PASS (NO-GO 기록 + 보완 문서 완료)</li>
<li><strong>Learning Hub 반영 포인트:</strong> Mac Terminal setup guide, required env keys (이름만), false NO-GO remediation 흐름</li>
</ul>
<hr>
<h2>Phase 26 — Run 017: 2020 Readiness Confirmation</h2>
<ul>
<li><strong>경로:</strong> <code>multi-agent-system/runs/run-017-2020-readiness-confirmation/</code></li>
<li><strong>목적:</strong> 2019 → 2020 이전 후 env readiness 및 wrapper dry-run 재확인.</li>
<li><strong>결과:</strong><ul>
<li>SLACK/HUB/HERMES readiness <strong>true</strong> (2020 Mac)</li>
<li>secret/env/token 파일 미복사; wrapper dry-run recheck pass</li>
<li><strong>NO LIVE EXECUTION YET</strong></li>
</ul>
</li>
<li><strong>상태:</strong> README only (formal PHASE report 없음)</li>
<li><strong>Learning Hub 반영 포인트:</strong> 마이그레이션 완료 기록, 2020-safe wrapper path 선행 조건, live 실행 전 게이트</li>
</ul>
<hr>
<h2>Phase 순서 요약표</h2>
<table>
<thead>
<tr>
<th>Phase</th>
<th>Run</th>
<th>제목</th>
<th>상태</th>
</tr>
</thead>
<tbody><tr>
<td>10</td>
<td>001</td>
<td>Production-like (LAB)</td>
<td>PASS</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>11</td>
<td>002</td>
<td>MCP Primary + Slack Stub</td>
<td>PASS</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>12</td>
<td>003</td>
<td>Hermes Stub</td>
<td>PASS</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>13</td>
<td>004</td>
<td>E2E Stub Chain</td>
<td>PASS</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>14</td>
<td>005</td>
<td>Gateway Contract Stub</td>
<td>PASS</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>15</td>
<td>006</td>
<td>Dry-run Gateway</td>
<td>PASS</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>16</td>
<td>007</td>
<td>Limited Live Pilot Design</td>
<td>PASS</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>17</td>
<td>008</td>
<td>Live Pilot Approval Package</td>
<td>PASS</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>18</td>
<td>009</td>
<td>Limited Live Preflight</td>
<td>PASS</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>19</td>
<td>010</td>
<td>Limited Live Pilot 001</td>
<td>PASS (조건부)</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>20</td>
<td>011</td>
<td>Live Blocker Readiness</td>
<td>PASS / NO-GO</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>21</td>
<td>012</td>
<td>Live Pilot Retry 001</td>
<td>PASS (BLOCKED)</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>22</td>
<td>013</td>
<td>Runtime Path Design</td>
<td>PASS</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>23</td>
<td>014</td>
<td>Wrapper Integration Dry-run</td>
<td>PASS</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>24</td>
<td>015</td>
<td>Live Retry 002 Env Readiness</td>
<td>PASS</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>25</td>
<td>016</td>
<td>Env False NO-GO Remediation</td>
<td>PASS (NO-GO)</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>26</td>
<td>017</td>
<td>2020 Readiness Confirmation</td>
<td>README only</td>
</tr>
</tbody></table>